The Ultimate Shower Showdown: Acrylic vs. Fiberglass – Which Is Better and Why?

Whether you’re building a new home and planning the design of your bathrooms or looking to replace an existing shower in your Nashville, Tennessee, home, you’re probably wondering which kind of shower to go with – acrylic or fiberglass. While fiberglass showers are quite attractive to homeowners given their lower price tag, affordability may be the only area in which fiberglass wins out.

Acrylic showers, though more expensive, generally last much longer than fiberglass showers. The difference in durability between these shower types has a lot to do with how they are manufactured. Acrylic showers are made from heated plastic-like materials that are stretched into a mold and then vacuumed to form the final shape. This mold-and-vacuum manufacturing process of acrylic showers produces shower stalls that are incredibly strong, scratch-resistant, and non-porous. Fiberglass showers, on the other hand, are made by pouring a liquid material into a gel-coated mold. The gel in the mold adheres to the fiberglass and protects it from water damage and bacterial growth. However, underneath the gel coating, the fiberglass is porous and, as the gel coating wears away over time, the fiberglass frame is exposed to water, which can cause cracks, rotting, mold, and a host of other problems.

That said, if you plan to stay in your home for a significant length of time, and would prefer a shower that will look great, require little maintenance, and serve you and your family well for many years to come, an acrylic shower is likely your best bet.

Stunning Bathroom Renovations from American Home Design

Since 1977, American Home Design has been the preferred bathroom remodeling company of Nashville homeowners. In our more than 40 years of business, we’ve helped countless residents increase the comfort, appearance, functionality, and safety of their bathrooms by installing top-of-the-line products that perform optimally and stand the test of time.

To learn more about partnering with us to have a new acrylic or fiberglass shower installed at your Nashville-area home, contact American Home Design today.

Get Your Project Started Today

50% OFF

Installation of Windows

Receive a free estimate for your next home upgrade

Window Project Inspiration

Window Installation

See the care and quality that goes into every job

View All Videos

Hear what American Home Design customers are saying!

If I could give more then 5 stars I would! They were professional, accommodating, and extremely knowledgeable. We had a few hitches in our giddyup and they were patient and understanding which was so appreciated! 10000% recommend over and over!

Chelsea C.

American Home Design has been so wonderful! Even after having our system for 6 months now, they still follow up with us to make sure we are still happy with our system to make sure everything is still working properly. I’ve never had anyone from any company stay in contact like that to make sure we are satisfied.

Lindsay L.

American Home Design was fantastic! They were personable and professional at the same time, cleaned up any mess left over from the work done, and was super accommodating. We will definitely be calling them for any future bathroom remodel needs!

Haley C.

The entire team especially our installers were amazing. They were so friendly, thorough and knowledgeable. They double checked everything and made sure everything was perfect before they left, and no mess left behind. I’m very happy with my new shower!

Sheila P.